One of the first non-English bands that I ever really got into was
Anglagard. Naturally, after becoming addicted to Hybris, I wanted
more. However, I also wanted to broaden my knowledge of different bands. So
rather than get Epilog, I got Sinkadus's Cirkus instead, after
reading endless comparisons of Sinkadus to Anglagard (as well as some
positive reviews of the album, from sources that I now know to consider ...
less than reliable).
The comparisons between the two bands are valid to an extent, as Sinkadus
sounds like a caricature of Anglagard. The flute, mellotron, organ, and
guitar work are pretty much all dead ringers for Anglagard (save for
typically being less proficient), and the presence of Lena Pettersson's
cello does little to create a distinctive sound. I can think of about a
half-dozen jokes that I could use to hammer this point home, and most of
them contain the word "Xerox". But I'll behave myself.
A derivative sound is far from being Sinkadus's worst failing, however.
That distinct honor would have to go to the band's lack of compositional
ability. The typical Sinkadus song (at least on this album) features the
band endlessly repeating patterns with little modulation until the
repetition becomes too much to bear. At that point, the band moves to a new
pattern, and the cycle of pain begins again. While repetition can be a
useful tool in creating a sense of drama, there are no such compelling
effects to be found here. After repeated listening, the distinction between
Anglagard and Sinkadus becomes crystal clear: where Anglagard is interesting
and dynamic, Sinkadus is predictable and flat. Where Anglagard introduces
new and captivating thematic material, Sinkadus continues to endlessly
repeat the theme they're currently hooked on.
I can't say that I hate this album, because there are a number of parts
that seem quite good. However, the band's insistence at running those parts
into the ground really hampers my enjoyment. The biggest crime I would
accuse Sinkadus of is wasted potential. I have a feeling that these guys and
gals *could* be good, but they just don't know how to turn some good ideas
into a full song. Some listeners may not mind the repetition, but I would
hight suggest hearing them before you buy.
|